RESULTS OF THE EIGHTEENTH JOHN COLLIER ANNUAL SURVEY ON SUSTAINABILITY - ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE, SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND GOOD GOVERNANCE (ESG) OF SOUTH AFRICAN GOLF COURSES.
TOP CLUB AWARD
The John Collier Survey’s data, which is received from golf clubs throughout South Africa, is combined with desktop research and interviews with people knowledgeable about golf courses throughout the region, and then analysed, following which we publish the John Collier Annual Survey in March each year.
After the publication, we then re-visit the data, in order to determine which golf club has submitted the most comprehensive report.
Within a 46% participation rate from golf clubs, and a 31% national compliance level, there will always clubs that stand out as being exceptional.
As has become the norm, there were a number of very strong contenders, however, we take this opportunity to congratulate,
UMHLALI COUNTRY CLUB
on winning the SUSTAINABILITY TOP CLUB AWARD in the John Collier Survey Report Review for 2024 – 2025, which is underpinned by the three pillars of sustainability namely, environmental compliance, social responsibility and good governance (ESG)
The work being done at UMHLALI COUNTRY CLUB is really very impressive, and it is fitting that on World Environment Day, the club’s efforts should be appropriately recognised.
Read more
World Environment Day (WED) is celebrated annually on 5 June, and its key objectives are to increase awareness about the environment, enhance political attention and encourage public action WED was established by the United Nations General Assembly in 1972, and over five decades, it has grown exponentially, and is now one of the largest global platforms for environmental outreach, with tens of millions of people participating online and through in-person activities, events, and actions around the world.
WED in 2025 focuses on ending plastic pollution, as this particular environmental scourge, exacerbates the deadly impacts of the triple planetary crisis – climate change, nature, land and biodiversity loss, and pollution and waste.
What UMHLALI COUNTRY CLUB did so well, in their survey questionnaire, was to illustrate its understanding of the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) such as SDG 3 (Good Health and Wellbeing), SDG 8 (Decent work and economic growth) and SDG 11(Sustainable Communities)which have become the common language of sustainability, and which are supported by the three pillars of sustainability namely, environmental, social and governance (ESG) policies and objectives.
This understanding was further demonstrated by the club’s strategic alignment through their published vision, values and mission statements. This vision is for the club to be the venue of choice for sports and recreation on the KZN North Coast, and to strive to provide members, guests and visitors with an affordable and beautiful eco-friendly club, with a top-rated golf course and sporting and recreational facilities, which in combination, offer an enjoyable experience, with quality service, in a hospitable and family-friendly environment.
In addition, the survey document submitted reflects the club’s values, which include, inter alia, a non-discriminatory organisation with professional management and service at its core, a commitment to social and environmental responsibility, in and through golf, a recognition of the importance of playing the club’s part to protect and restore nature, conserve resources, take meaningful climate action and strengthen communities.
Furthermore, the Umhlali survey report illustrates how the club seeks to use its reach to raise awareness and positive action amongst golfers, partners and the wider public, and live the commitment to make an important difference, and help golf become a valued leader in sustainability.
What the board and management illustrated in the survey questionnaire is their understanding of the relevance of the ESG principles, and the importance of the SDGs for UMHLALI COUNTRY CLUB. It is this understanding that has laid the groundwork, by setting a sustainability approach that takes into consideration the positive and negative impacts of their business on the ESG risks and opportunities, and setting up short, and long-term, environmental compliance, social responsibility and good governance goals that are aligned with the ESG and SDGs, overseeing the progress on them, and then reporting, and engaging with stakeholders.
UMHLALI’S understanding, and implementation of the three pillars of sustainability, namely environmental compliance, social responsibility, and good governance (ESG), sets a standard that many clubs in South Africa would want to emulate.
Notwithstanding UMHLALI’S award, special mention must also be made of the READING COUNTRY CLUB and DE ZALZE GOLF CLUB, in their efforts towards sustainability and its three ESG pillars.
Winning a SUSTAINABILITY TOP CLUB AWARD is only achieved with the support of very committed and passionate people, who are prepared to wholly embrace sustainability, and its three ESG pillars, in an integrated and methodical manner.
Therefore, special congratulations must go to UMHLALI COUNTRY CLUB, members, the Chairman and Governing Body, the general manager Derick Reinke, sports manager Jason Herbst and course superintendent Robin Naicker.Â
JOHN COLLIER, JOHANNESBURG
21 May 2025
HOW DOES MY CLUB BECOME ELIGIBLE FOR THE TOP CLUB AWARD?
Eligibility & to qualify to be judged in this category, is based simply upon ‘signing-on’, as a participating club in the John Collier Survey.
Once your club has ‘entered’ the programme, at the end of each year the data collected is analysed by John Collier Survey, and each club is assigned a level of certification – Bronze, Silver or Gold – based on the results of this data.
All certified clubs have shown a sustained level of commitment, but naturally, only the Gold Level certified clubs will be in the running to receive the Top Club Award each year.
With the addition of the Top Province Award, every club now has a role to play in supporting its provinces’ chances of winning this prestigious accolade.
The reason why each club’s individual activities are important is that the winner of the Top Province Award is determined by the aggregated contributions made by each province’s member club.
HOW DO I ENTER THE AWARDS?
All Gold Level certified clubs are automatically ‘in the running’ to win the John Collier Survey’s Top Club Award each year.
Every club, which has received any level of certification, has shown a sustained level of commitment to their responsibility to be good corporate citizens and to safeguard the environment, but naturally only the Gold Level certified clubs will qualify to receive the Top Club Award each year.
Winners of this prestigious award include:
AWARD YEAR
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
TOP CLUB AWARD WINNERS
Benoni Country Club
Randpark Golf Club
Leopard Creek Golf Club
Kyalami Country Club
Leopard Creek Golf Club
Metropolitan Golf Club
Pretoria Country Club
Paarl Golf Club
Umhlali Country Club
Bryanston Country Club
Kingswood Golf Club
Umhlali Country Club
St Francis Links
Sabi River Sun Golf Club
Blair Atholl Golf Estate
Elements Private Reserve
Umhlali Country Club
SPECIAL MENTION AWARD WINNERS
Devonvale Golf Estate
Stellenbosch Golf Club
East London Golf Club
Woodhill Country Club, State Mines Country Club
Victoria Country Club, Gowrie Farm Golf Club
Leopard Creek Golf Club, Royal Durban Golf Club
Ebotse Golf Estate
Zebula Golf Estate
Woodhill Country Club, Paarl Golf Club
Prince’s Grant Golf Estate, Umhlali Country Club
Waterkloof Golf Club, Champagne Sports
Gary Player Country Club, Lost City Golf Course
Eagle Canyon Golf Club
Umhlali Country Club, George Golf Club
Elements Private Reserve
Umhlali Country Club, Olivewood Private Estate
Reading Country Club, De Zalze Golf Club
Â
PREVIOUS TOP CLUB AWARD WINNERS

Elements Private Reserve
2023/2024

Blair Atholl Golf Estate
2022/2023

Sabi River Sun Golf Club
2021/2022
